Breaking Records: Semisonic's 'Fine' isn't worth the cost

When only half of an album is worth listening to, should music fans pay the whole $15 for a CD?

Those who say no should probably stay away from Semisonic's "Feeling Strangely Fine." But listeners who are willing to risk $7.50 can look forward to six great songs.

Semisonic's second album, "Feeling Strangely Fine," features the single "Closing Time," an outstanding song that has captivated radio listeners across the country. "Closing Time" is by far the best song on the album. Its thoughtful lyrics and arrangement make it worthy of radio airplay.

Although the other five songs that bring quality to this album are not quite as good, they are still catchy, honest and a little confusing. That confusion, particularly in Semisonic's lyrics, is the key to the album's best songs.

Perplexing in its message and moody in its guitars and vocals, the song "Made to Last" is a prime example of musical beauty on "Feeling Strangely Fine." Lyricist/vocalist Dan Wilson's words at first seem like mere babble. But before the piano and the slide guitar kick in, he neatly ties everything together with lyrical elegance. This song, like the other five, is so emotionally driven that it is leaves listeners contemplating every word, synchronized with the cracks in Wilson's voice. In these six songs, Semisonic shines in all aspects of music.

But the other six songs pale in comparison.

REVIEW
Semisonic

Feeling Strangely Fine
MCA
2 1/2 stars

Reviewed by
Daily Arts Writer
Jewel Gopwani

Lacking any complexity in musicianship and lyrics, Semisonic dumbs down its ability, hoping fans will lower their expectations. Songs such as "California" and "Secret Smile" seem contrived, showing only the potential that Semisonic has already surpassed in "Closing Time" and "Made to Last."

Although these songs are not downright terrible, they are what listeners would expect from any mediocre pop band, not from Semisonic. At most, the tracks, "Completely Pleased" and "Secret Smile" - which are about having good luck with women - are borderline easy-listening songs.

Not only are half of the songs mediocre, the order in which the songs are in leaves much to be desired. "Closing Time" is the opening track. Half of the people who purchase the album probably won't get past this hit. For those who manage to hear it out, most of the quality songs are at the beginning, with two near the end. The album closes on a disappointing note.

Semisonic is still a young band. Even though there are not very many hits on this album, it is a step in the right direction. By following its natural instincts in songwriting, composing and playing, Semisonic's next effort should be something out of the ordinary - an album that is worth its price.

03-24-98

Previous Article Next Article

HOME| NEWS| EDITORIAL| ARTS| SPORTS| ARCHIVES|


©1998 The Michigan Daily
Letters to the editor
should be sent to:
daily.letters@umich.edu
Comments about this site
should be sent to:
online.daily@umich.edu